Candidates Rich and Poor Competing

0
1011
Steve Adler

Occupational income, investments, debts, real estate, business interests, and much more detailed in filings

Investigative Report by Ken Martin

Updated Wednesday, October 1, 2014 10:52am to add Delia Garza’s loans to her campaign

Updated Thursday October 2, 2014 6:07am to identify Jimmy Paver as a District 7 candidate

Steve Adler
Steve Adler

Mayoral candidate Stephen Ira “Steve” Adler is clearly the wealthiest candidate running for city office, while his two chief opponents, incumbent Council Members Sheryl Nelson Cole and Michael William “Mike” Martinez, are merely well off, comparatively speaking, based on a review of their sworn financial statements.

These financial statements are separate and apart from the contribution and expenditure reports required in connection with election campaigns.

Personal resources provide a significant advantage if candidates choose to invest in their campaigns. But that advantage is diminished if not accompanied by the work it takes to build a broad base of support.

Campaigns are not won with checkbooks alone, but according to Campaign Finance Reports filed July 15, which reflected fundraising and expenditures through June 30, 21 candidates had already loaned their campaigns a combined half-million dollars—$509,926 (not $504,911 as first stated) to be exact. (More about that later.) The next batch of campaign finance reports, due October 5, will no doubt reflect even more personal spending to finance political ambitions.

The Austin Bulldog’s investigation of personal finances illustrates the vastly different resources the candidates can bring to bear as they race toward the November 4 election. And to carry them through to the December 16 runoff—if they make the initial cut. This analysis indicates the candidates range from the mega-wealthy to the downright poor. One of the candidates reported drawing unemployment benefits last year.

Shining light in dark corners

Under state law and Austin City Code candidates and incumbents must file two different kinds of sworn financial statements. Both kinds of statements must be signed and sworn to as being true, correct, and fully complete showing all required information, and are submitted under penalty of perjury.

However, unlike campaign finance reports—which are posted for easy public access on the Internet—these financial statements are kept on file in the City Clerk’s office.

Through requests filed under the Texas Public Information Act, The Austin Bulldog obtained statements filed by the candidates and publishes them here as part of our mission to bring more transparency to local government and allow increased scrutiny of those elected by permitting citizens to monitor their actions for possible conflicts of interest.

Links for each candidate’s statements are provided at the bottom of this article.

In addition, The Austin Bulldog constructed a spreadsheet, Financial Statements for 2014 Candidates for Mayor and City Council, that provides an overview of sources of income for each candidate and for the candidate’s spouse or domestic partner.

The City Clerk notified candidates of the requirement to file these statements in a May 5, 2014, memo. The City Clerk also published a Candidate Packet that contains links to the forms to be used. (See Tab 6 of the Packet.) Yet eight of the candidates failed to file one or both of the statements.

State Personal Financial Statement

Non-incumbent candidates were required by Local Government Code Chapter 145.004 to file a Personal Financial Statement by 5pm September 8, 2014. (Incumbents filed their reports in April.)

It should be noted that these statements cover the candidates’ financial activity in 2013 and that information is now nine months old.

Personal Financial Statements are not only kept out of public view but in accordance with Local Government Code Section 145.007(b), will be released by the City Clerk’s office only after the requestor completes a form that indicates the date of the request, the name and address of the requestor, and the name of the organization the requestor represents.

It seems the legislators want to be able to track who is snooping into their personal business, but the same rule governing access applies at every level of Texas government.

The good news—so far as public access is concerned—is that nothing prevents media organizations from getting copies of Personal Financial Statements (after filling out a form for each of the 78 candidates, as The Austin Bulldog did for this investigation) and posting them online.

This is the fourth straight year that The Austin Bulldog has obtained and published current financial statements for the mayor, council members, and candidates (although this investigation does not include the incumbents who are not running for election).

As required by Local Government Code Section 145.008 the City Clerk’s office on September 10 notified the City Attorney of failure to timely file a Personal Financial Statement. Notification was furnished in a Memo to City Attorney and Integrity Officer Re: Late Filings.

A copy of the memo, obtained with a public information request, indicates that 17 candidates did not timely file a Personal Financial Statement.

The Austin Bulldog’s follow-up requests for copies of late statements showed that six of the 17 candidates still had not filed by September 18. The other 11 candidates filed after the deadline.

The six candidates who did not file a Personal Financial Statement are:

• Mayoral candidates Ronald J. “Ron” Culver and Todd Howell Phelps.

• District 1 candidate Samuel Amerchi “Sam” Osemene.

• District 2 candidate John Charles Sheppard (who filed September 24 after being contacted by The Austin Bulldog).

• District 3 candidate Julian Limon Fernandez (who after being contacted by The Austin Bulldog said he would file September 29).

• District 3 candidate Eric Javier Rangel.

A candidate commits an offense for knowingly failing to file a Personal Financial Statement, according to Local Government Code Section 145.009. Such offenses are a Class B misdemeanor.

The City Attorney is tasked by Local Government Code Section 145.010(b) to notify by certified mail those candidates who failed to file a Personal Financial Statement. Candidates who fail to file before the 30th day after receiving such notice is civilly liable for an amount not to exceed $1,000.

The Austin Bulldog filed a public information request September 25 for copies of letters or other correspondence the City Attorney has sent to candidates who failed to file. That request is still pending.

City Statement of Financial Information

In addition the state-mandated Personal Financial Statement, non-incumbent candidates were required by City Code Section 2-7-74 to file a Statement of Financial Information by August 25, 2014. (Incumbents filed these statements in April and submitted updates in July.)

Seven candidates did not file a Statement of Financial Information, according to the City Clerk’s response to The Austin Bulldog’s public information request for copies. These candidates are:

• Mayoral candidates Ronald J. “Ron” Culver and Randall Forrest Stephens.

• District 1 candidates Valerie Monique Menard and Samuel Amerchi “Sam” Osemene

• District 3 candidates Julian Limon Fernandez, Jose “Joe” Quintero Sr., and Eric Javier Rangel

City Code Section 2-7-99 provides a penalty for failure to file in the form of a fine not exceeding $500. City Code Section 2-7-41 sets forth the procedure for filing sworn complaints about violations, which are subject to hearings by the City’s Ethics Review Commission.

Key differences in the two statements

Control over assetsGovernment Code Section 572.023(a) requires Personal Financial Statements to include the financial activity of the candidate or elected official’s “spouse and dependent children” if the filer “had actual control over that activity for the preceding calendar year.”

City Code provides no such exemption, hence there is a significant difference in the financial activity reported in the two statements when the filer chooses to exercise that option, e.g., City Council Member Mike Martinez, who always omits significant investments from his Personal Financial Statement that are reflected in the Statement of Financial Information.

Domestic partnersCity Code Section 2-7-71(2) defines “Spouse” to include a “domestic partner, which means an individual who lives in the same household and shares common resources of life in a close, personal, intimate relationship with the City official if under Texas law the individual would not be prevented from marrying the City official on account of age, consanguinity, or prior undissolved marriage to another. A domestic partner may be of the same, or opposite, gender as the City official.”

City Code requires reporting the financial activity of domestic partners.

State law does not address the issue of domestic partnerships, so such reporting is not required in Personal Financial Statements.

Candidate demographics

Aside from personal wealth, or the lack of it, the overarching trends revealed in the records of those who filed:

Marital status—A total of 29 candidates, or 37 percent, did not report having a spouse or domestic partner.

Business ownership—A total of 25 candidates (or their spouses) have an ownership interest in a business, other than just owning stock in a company. Mayoral candidate Adler, with wife Diane Tipton Land, heads that list with 24.

Investments—Thirty-nine candidates reported having stocks or equity ownerships valued at more than $5,000. District 10 candidate Marjorie Pressley “Margie” Burciaga topped that list with 105 such investments. The total value of investments are not reported, only that the candidates have a substantial interest.

Non-occupational income—Thirty-two candidates reported having sources of income exceeding $5,000 each that came from interest, dividends, royalties, rents, trust disbursements or other non-occupational sources. Adler headed that list, too, with 24 such sources.

Property ownership— District 7 candidate Jefferson Elmer “Jeb” Boyt and District 9 candidate (and incumbent) Kathryne B. ‘Kathie” Tovo lead this category with 11 properties each, while 24 candidates who filed statements reported owning no real estate.

Demographics— A person’s birthdate is not disclosed in financial statements but The Austin Bulldog’s research through other records and verified with candidates indicates the oldest person on the ballot is District 1 candidate Norman Jacobson, 76. The youngest is District 4 candidate Greg Casar, 25.

The average age of all 78 candidates is 48.

District 2 candidates have the youngest average age, 39, but District 8 candidates run a close second with an average age of 40.

Personal spending already topped $500,000

None of the candidates in Districts 1 and 2 (deleted District 2) had made loans to their campaigns through June 30.

Candidates in all other contests boosted their campaigns, including:

• Mayor candidate Steve Adler $194,000. He’s an outsider facing two incumbents on the City Council since 2006: Sheryl Cole and Mike Martinez, neither of whom have dipped into personal funds so far.

• District 10 candidate Robert Thomas $100,000. Thomas ran unsuccessfully for state representative in 2012 as a Republican trying to unset Democrat Donna Howard.

• District 8 candidate Becky Bray $50,000. District 8 is the only contest in which every candidate is literally buying into a campaign.

• District 7 candidate Jimmy Paver $40,000 (not District 8 as first stated).

• District 5 candidate Ann Kitchen $20,700.

• District 9 candidate Kathie Tovo $15,000. She still has $61,807 in campaign debt from previous years, but that’s a formality, given that just one of her and husband Tom Hurt’s reported sources of non-occupational income, Ratliff Riker LP, grossed $900,000 in 2013 from sales of oil, gas, and surface easements.

• District 3 candidate Fred McGhee $12,500.

• District 8 candidate Eliza May $12,000.

• District 6 candidate Jay Wiley $11,025.

• District 7 candidate Ed English $10,000.

• District 8 candidate Ed Scruggs $6,264.

• District 7 candidate Jeb Boyt $5,025.

• District 2 candidate Delia Garza $5,025 (added to correct omission as first published)

• District 10 candidate Margie Burciaga $5,000.

• District 10 candidate Matt Lamon $5,000.

• District 5 candidate Mike Rodriguez $5,000.

• District 8 candidate Ellen Troxclair $5,000.

• District 10 candidate Jason Meeker $3,267.

• District 8 candidate Darrell Pierce $2,500.

• District 4 candidate Laura Pressley $2,000.

• District 7 candidate Melissa Zone $550.

• District 10 candidate Mandy Dealey $100.

Links to financial statements

In these links the names of statements are abbreviated, as follows:

• PFS is the Personal Financial Statement required by the Local Government Code.

• SFI is the Statement of Financial Information required by City Code.

DNF indicates the candidate did not file the statement, according to the City Clerk’s office.

Mayoral candidates

Stephen Ira “Steve” Adler PFS

Stephen Ira “Steve” Adler SFI

Sheryl Nelson Cole PFS

Sheryl Nelson Cole SFI With July Update

Ronald J. “Ron” Culver PFS DNF

Ronald J. “Ron” Culver SFI DNF

Mary Catherine Krenek PFS

Mary Catherine Krenek SFI

Michael William “Mike” Martinez PFS

Michael William “Mike” Martinez SFI With July Update

David Martin Orshalick PFS

David Martin Orshalick SFI

Todd Howell Phelps PFS DNF

Todd Howell Phelps SFI

Randall Forrest Stephens PFS

Randall Forrest Stephens SFI DNF

District 1 Candidates

Andrew Joseph Bucknall PFS

Andrew Joseph Bucknall SFI

Michael Denard Cargill PFS

Michael Denard Cargill SFI

George William Hindman PFS

George William Hindman SFI

Ora Elliott Houston PFS

Ora Elliott Houston SFI

Christopher J. “Chris” Hutchins PFS

Christopher J. “Chris” Hutchins SFI

Norman Andes Jacobson PFS

Norman Andes Jacobson SFI

DeWayne William Lofton PFS

DeWayne William Lofton SFI

Valerie Monique Menard PFS

Valerie Monique Menard SFI DNF

Samuel Amechi “Sam” Osemene PFS DNF

Samuel Amechi “Sam” Osemene SFI DNF

District 2 Candidates

Delia Aileen Garza PFS

Delia Aileen Garza SFI

Michael James “Mike” Owen PFS

Michael James “Mike” Owen SFI

Edward A. “Wally” Reyes Jr. PFS

Edward A. “Wally” Reyes Jr. SFI

John Charles Sheppard PFS

John Charles Sheppard SFI

District 3 Candidates

Susana Renteria Almanza PFS

Susana Renteria Almanza SFI

Mario G. Cantu PFS

Mario G. Cantu SFI

Julian Limon Fernandez PFS DNF

Julian Limon Fernandez SFI DNF

Christopher Lee “Chris” Hoerster PFS

Christopher Lee “Chris” Hoerster SFI

Shaun Dylan Ireland PFS

Shaun Dylan Ireland SFI

Fred L. McGhee PFS

Fred L. McGhee SFI

Kent Kimball Phillips PFS

Kent Kimball Phillips SFI

Jose “Joe” Quintero Sr. PFS

Jose “Joe” Quintero Sr. SFI DNF

Eric Javier Rangel PFS DNF

Eric Javier Rangel SFI DNF

Sabino “Pio” Renteria PFS

Sabino “Pio” Renteria SFI

Ricardo Turullois-Bonilla PFS

Ricardo Turullois-Bonilla SFI

Jose Antonio Valera PFS

Jose Antonio Valera SFI

District 4 Candidates

Gregorio Eduardo “Greg” Casar PFS

Gregorio Eduardo “Greg” Casar SFI

Katrina Michelle Daniel PFS

Katrina Michelle Daniel SFI

Monica Ann Guzman PFS

Monica Ann Guzman SFI

Louis Clarence Herrin III PFS

Louis Clarence Herrin III SFI

Marco Mancillas PFS

Marco Mancillas SFI

Sharon Elise Mays PFS

Sharon Elise Mays SFI

Roberto Perez Jr. PFS

Roberto Perez Jr. SFI

Laura Ann Pressley PFS

Laura Ann Pressley SFI

District 5 Candidates

Daniel Lawrence “Dan” Buda PFS

Daniel Lawrence “Dan” Buda SFI

Jason R. Denny PFS

Jason R. Denny SFI

William David “Dave” Floyd PFS

William David “Dave” Floyd SFI

CarolAnneRose Kennedy PFS

CarolAnneRose Kennedy SFI

Ann Elizabeth Kitchen PFS

Ann Elizabeth Kitchen SFI

Luis Miguel “Mike” Rodriguez PFS

Luis Miguel “Mike” Rodriguez SFI

David Craig Senecal PFS

David Craig Senecal SFI

District 6 Candidates

James Timothy “Jimmy” Flannigan PFS

James Timothy “Jimmy” Flannigan SFI

Mackenzie-Anne Kelly PFS

Mackenzie-Anne Kelly SFI

Lloyd Gordon “Pete” Phillips Jr. PFS

Lloyd Gordon “Pete” Phillips Jr. SFI

Matthew Duane “Matt” Stillwell PFS

Matthew Duane “Matt” Stillwell SFI

Jay Byron Wiley PFS

Jay Byron Wiley SFI

Donald Shelly “Don” Zimmerman PFS

Donald Shelly “Don” Zimmerman SFI

District 7 Candidates

Jefferson Elmer “Jeb” Boyt PFS

Jefferson Elmer “Jeb” Boyt SFI

Edwin Edgar “Ed” English PFS

Edwin Edgar “Ed” English SFI

Zachary Ray “Zack” Ingraham PFS

Zachary Ray “Zack” Ingraham SFI

James Anthony “Jimmy” Paver PFS

James Anthony “Jimmy” Paver SFI

Leslie Howard Pool PFS

Leslie Howard Pool SFI

Pete A. Salazar Jr. PFS

Pete A. Salazar Jr. SFI

Darryl Robert Wittle PFS

Darryl Robert Wittle SFI

Melissa Ann Zone PFS

Melissa Ann Zone SFI

District 8 Candidates

Rebecca Anne “Becky” Bray PFS

Rebecca Anne “Becky” Bray SFI

Eliza May PFS

Eliza May SFI

Darrell W. Pierce PFS

Darrell W. Pierce SFI

Edward Scott “Ed” Scruggs PFS

Edward Scott “Ed” Scruggs SFI

Ellen Gale Troxclair PFS

Ellen Gale Troxclair SFI

District 9 Candidates

Erin Kendra McGann PFS

Erin Kendra McGann SFI

Christopher John “Chris” Riley PFS

Christopher John “Chris” Riley SFI With July Update

Kathryne B. “Kathie” Tovo PFS

Kathryne B. “Kathie” Tovo SFI With July Update

District 10 Candidates

Marjorie Presley “Margie” Burciaga PFS

Marjorie Presley “Margie” Burciaga SFI

Audrey Christine “Tina” Cannon PFS

Audrey Christine “Tina” Cannon SFI

Amanda Mayhew “Mandy” Dealey PFS

Amanda Mayhew “Mandy” Dealey SFI

Sheri Perry Gallo PFS

Sheri Perry Gallo SFI

Matthew Lamar “Matt” Lamon PFS

Matthew Lamar “Matt” Lamon SFI

Jason Warren Meeker PFS

Jason Warren Meeker SFI

Robert Dartanian Thomas PFS

Robert Dartanian Thomas SFI

William Lee “Bill” Worsham PFS

William Lee “Bill” Worsham SFI

The Austin Bulldog operates as a 501(c)3 nonprofit and depends upon the community it serves for support. You can help fund our investigative reporting by making a tax-deductible contribution. Now is an especially good time to contribute as it would help us to raise matching funds for a $50,000 Challenge Grant that would provide a quantum increase in the volume of high-quality reporting we are able to publish.

Related Bulldog coverage:

Austin Governed By the Well-to-Do: November 2014 elections may deliver economic diversity to next city council, May 17, 2013

Some Council Members’ Finances Change Significantly: Mayor carries campaign debt, Riley adds domestic partner, Martinez adds investments, Cole reports spouse separately, and Tovo pays off $528,000 in real estate loans, August 22, 2012

How Rich Are Austin’s Mayor and Council Members? Most are pretty well off by local standards, with extensive holdings in real estate and investments, June 27, 2012

Background Investigation: Mike Martinez: Here’s what the public records say about the council member running for re-election, February 25, 2012

Background Investigation: Sheryl Cole: Here’s what the public records say about the council member running for reelection, January 13, 2012

City Council Martinez Reports Big Gains in Financial Assets: May have filed to report major investments in his last annual report, August 17, 2011

Council Members Riley and Shade May Have Violated City Code: Sworn financial statements give public tools to monitor their elected officials, June 2, 2011.